Absence of Multiple Information Questions
Rizzi (1978) notes a curious property of Italian (see also McCloskey 1979 for a similar claim about Irish): this language does not allow multiple wh questions at all.
(1)

An intriguing explanation for this ban has been offered by Calabrese (1984, 1992): Italian does not have the second focus position required to license the additional wh-element. Calabrese’s reasoning goes as follows. A multiple wh-question, if not used as an echo or quiz question, asks for new information regarding all wh-elements; new information in a declarative sentence is construed with nondefault sentential stress—or focus. The type of focus relevant for a felicitous reply to a question is information (or presentational) focus, not identificational (or contrastive) focus (see the discussion in E ´. Kiss 1998). In Italian, the position for information focus is unique, and so it follows that multiple wh-questions are ill formed: the multiple information requested cannot be realized in the answer.
(2)

This state of affairs is independent of interpretation in terms of single pair and pair-list readings, as Calabrese shows (see Grohmann 2003a for discussion).
(3)

The intended interpretation of (51) is not contrastive, but information focus (cf. ‘What did people write, and who did it?’), hence the a. (Presumably, an utterance like (51) is felicitous and well formed in a con text that focuses contrast.) As it turns out, we can detect a similar effect in German: the analogue of (51) can only be used contrastively as well.
It seems that German and Italian pattern alike in the relevant proper ties. In a sense, then, German multiple wh-questions are not really questions. However, German has the option of marking contrastiveness in two positions: by fronting the relevant element or by assigning it heavy stress in low position. Thus, if a question is formed that asks for contrastive information (in a syntactically well-formed way), a possible answer is also well formed syntactically.
If German shares with Italian the absence of ‘‘real’’ (information) multiple wh-questions, the notion of wh-topic—or the analysis of movement to Spec,TopP, for that matter—loses some of its initial awkwardness. More evidence against such awkwardness follows directly. Let me just briefly remark on and relativize earlier conclusions that the Italian connection might o¤er a clue about why some structures do not seem to in volve movement to TopP of the lower wh-phrase (see especially the data in the discussion of parasitic gaps in section 10.3.2): maybe German does have real multiple wh-questions, but they are (possibly) rare and show different properties than those I have considered throughout.