Assessing Creativity through Common Consensus Discussion

The assessment result

The study obtained high coefficients in the statistical tests for reliability and inter-reliability. One possible reason of course is the success of the research method in generating a rubric that is agreed on by teachers in the context. Instead of adopting a standard instrument, the study applied the Delphi method to generate a set of criteria that was agreed on by the majority of teachers as suitable for assessing students' creativity in filmmaking. Hence, when they applied these criteria in the actual assessment activity, high agreement among them was achieved. As Amabile put it, "...experts in a domain do share creativity criteria to a reasonable degree." (1983, p.38).

However, one has to be aware that even with the rubric created, if assessors assess a creative work with an overall impression instead of examining it item by item, it may also result in high inter-reliability among assessment items. This was actually reflected by one of the assessors in the discussion after the assessment activity. She found the session was too long and felt fatigued by the end and tended to grade students' films according to overall impression. This shows that even with a good assessment tool, if the way of applying it is inappropriate, negative effects may arise.

However, at the minimum, there is no indication that the process or tool has a negative impact on the ability to assess for creativity. It appears that participating in a long discussion process and using a rubric that breaks down creativity into an array of items in several categories does not confuse or prevent teachers from identifying and assessing the creativity of a given work. A further study to support or refute these possibilities is in the planning stage.

اخر الاخبار

اخبار العتبة العباسية المقدسة

سماحة السيد الصافي يكرم عددًا من عوائل الشهداء ضمن فعاليات مهرجان روح النبوة النسوي العالمي الثامن

إحدى أمهات الشهداء: نعتز بتضحيات أبنائنا ونفتخر بشهادتهم دفاعًا عن الدين والمقدسات

ضمن فعاليات مهرجان روح النبوة… عرض فيلم يوثق نشاطات الشعب النسوية في العتبة العباسية المقدسة

فعاليات مهرجان روح النبوة الثقافي تشهد تقديم أوبريت الثقلين القرآني

المزيد

الآخبار الصحية

طبيب يكشف أفضل مكمل غذائي لتحسين المزاج ودعم الصحة النفسية

دراسة جديدة تكشف أضرار الأطعمة الجاهزة على القلب ؟

6 أطعمة طبيعية تهدئ الزكام دون أدوية.. تعرف عليهم

ماذا يحدث لأعراض الزكام عند تناول الثوم بانتظام؟

المزيد

الآخبار التكنلوجية

ابتكار ثوري في بطاريات السيارات الكهربائية.. سعة أعلى 4 مرات

ماذا يحدث لجسمك عند شرب الماء الساخن يوميا؟

7 فوائد "خفية" لشرب شاي الكركديه كل يوم

دراسة تكشف قدرة الحيتان على سماع الأصوات منخفضة وعالية التردد من مسافة بعيدة

المزيد

مواضيع ذات صلة

Review matching exercise and answer key – Part II

Can Assessment of Student Attitudes Assist both the Teaching and Learning Process as well as Ultimate Performance in Professional Practice Conclusions

Can Assessment of Student Attitudes Assist both the Teaching and Learning Process as well as Ultimate Performance in Professional Practice Brief overview of third year OT Program at Newcastle University

Can Assessment of Student Attitudes Assist both the Teaching and Learning Process as well as Ultimate Performance in Professional Practice Background

Can Assessment of Student Attitudes Assist both the Teaching and Learning Process as well as Ultimate Performance in Professional Practice

Assessing Creativity through Common Consensus Conclusions

Assessing Creativity through Common Consensus Discussion The assessment rubric

Assessing Creativity through Common Consensus Discussion The Delphi survey

Delphi method Stage 3 Assessment activity The assessment results

Delphi method Stage 3 Assessment activity Conducting assessment

Delphi method Stage 3 Assessment activity Creative video projects

Delphi method Stage 3 Assessment activity Selecting sample